How Do Mortgage Brokers Sell More Protection?
Protection insurance is one of the most important yet underutilised tools in a mortgage broker’s toolkit. Many mortgage brokers want to sell more life insurance, critical illness cover, and income protection, but struggle to move beyond the basics or make protection a consistent part of their process. So, how can mortgage brokers consistently sell more protection insurance to benefit both their business and their clients?
Why Is Belief in Protection Insurance Essential for Mortgage Brokers?
One of the biggest factors influencing protection insurance sales is the broker’s personal conviction. Clients can tell immediately if you’re recommending life insurance, income protection, or critical illness cover just because you have to—not because you genuinely believe in the value. If you wouldn’t buy the cover yourself, why should they?
As a mortgage broker, the first step to selling more protection insurance is to review your own cover. Ask yourself: “Would I recommend my current protection insurance policy to a loved one?” If not, take action and sort out your own policies first. Authentic belief is powerful—when you speak from genuine conviction, your clients will sense it and are far more likely to take your advice seriously.
When Should Mortgage Brokers Introduce Protection Insurance in the Sales Process?
Timing is everything in protection insurance sales. Many mortgage brokers make the classic mistake of introducing protection insurance as an afterthought, once the mortgage deal is nearly complete. At that point, the client is often exhausted by paperwork and sees insurance as just another extra cost.
The best mortgage brokers introduce protection insurance early, ideally during the initial discovery call. From the start, position protection as an integral part of your advisory service—not a bolt-on. For example, set the agenda by saying, “Alongside your mortgage, we’ll review how to make sure your home, your income, and your family are protected.” This positions you as a holistic adviser, not just a mortgage broker.
How Can Mortgage Brokers Make Protection Insurance Relevant for Clients?
Clients buy protection insurance when it feels relevant to their lives. Instead of rattling off policy features, make your protection insurance pitch about the client. Use real-life scenarios tailored to their situation—such as “What would happen to your family if you couldn’t work for six months due to illness?” or “Would your partner be able to keep up mortgage payments without your income?”
Open-ended questions help mortgage brokers uncover the real needs and concerns that drive protection insurance sales. Always anchor the discussion to what matters most to the client—their family, home, and lifestyle. Avoid jargon and keep your explanations clear and focused on outcomes.
What Is the Best Structure for a Protection Insurance Conversation?
Structure is crucial for mortgage brokers who want to improve their protection insurance sales. Start with the facts—income, dependents, current cover, liabilities—then transition into what those facts mean for the client’s security.
The most effective mortgage brokers use a “protection gap” calculator or worksheet to visually demonstrate any shortfall in cover. This helps clients see the need for protection insurance in real terms, rather than abstract figures. Once the gap is clear, connect the emotional impact: “If you lost your income, how long could you keep your home?” This combination of logic and emotion is key to helping clients take action.
How Can Mortgage Brokers Make Protection Insurance a Standard Part of Every Client Journey?
Consistency breeds confidence, both for you and your clients. The highest performing mortgage brokers have a set process for discussing protection insurance with every single client, regardless of case size or perceived need. By making protection insurance a standard topic—just like discussing interest rates or lender criteria—you normalise the conversation and make it clear this is about proper advice, not a sales pitch.
Have a script or framework for your protection conversation so you never have to “wing it.” This ensures no client falls through the cracks and every opportunity for income protection, life cover, or critical illness insurance is explored.
How Does Storytelling and Social Proof Help Mortgage Brokers Sell More Protection Insurance?
People remember stories, not statistics. Mortgage brokers who successfully sell more protection insurance share real-world case studies—anonymised if needed—that show how clients have benefitted from the right cover. For example: “I recently worked with a couple in a similar situation, and when the unexpected happened, their income protection meant they could focus on recovery, not bills.”
Use testimonials, Google reviews, and especially simple case studies in your process, your marketing, and your content. This builds social proof and demonstrates your expertise and trustworthiness as a protection insurance adviser.
What Common Mistakes Should Mortgage Brokers Avoid When Selling Protection Insurance?
Waiting too late to discuss protection insurance—don’t leave it until the end.
Focusing only on product features, not client outcomes.
Relying on jargon or complex policy explanations.
Making it optional instead of presenting it as an essential part of good mortgage advice.
Not following up—sometimes clients need a second conversation to make a decision.
By avoiding these mistakes and following a structured process, mortgage brokers can dramatically increase both protection insurance uptake and client satisfaction.
Why Should Mortgage Brokers See Protection Insurance as a Service, Not Just a Sale?
Protection insurance is about more than hitting targets. The best mortgage brokers see it as a core service that adds value, deepens client relationships, and truly protects people’s lives. When you treat income protection, life insurance, and critical illness cover as fundamental to your role as a mortgage adviser, clients will too.
Conclusion: How Can Mortgage Brokers Sell More Protection Insurance Consistently?
To consistently sell more protection insurance, mortgage brokers must:
Believe in the value of the cover themselves
Introduce protection early in every client journey
Anchor advice to client needs, not just policies
Follow a consistent structure and process
Share stories and social proof to build trust
By making these principles part of your mortgage business, you will increase your protection insurance sales, help more clients achieve true financial security, and stand out as a trusted adviser in the UK mortgage market.
Ready to grow your mortgage business faster?
Get my FREE 30-Day Mortgage Broker Boost—that’s 30 daily emails packed with actionable quick wins to help you grow your mortgage business, improve your sales, and build better client relationships.
Start your free 30-day challenge now: ashborland.com/30day
